The Pittsburgh Penguins have a history of discovering hidden gems and turning them into key contributors. With the 2026-27 season on the horizon, it's time to explore some potential surprise players who could make a significant impact. While some names are more likely than others, the beauty of the game lies in these unexpected twists and turns.
Declan Carlile: The Rising Defender
One player who could surprise many is Declan Carlile. The Penguins have a knack for spotting undervalued defenders and propelling their careers, as seen with Wotherspoon and Shea. Carlile, a left-handed defenseman, has the potential to become a top-four matchup defender. His underlying metrics suggest a player with NHL-ready skills, and if he can slot into a top-four role, it would be a significant surprise. However, with only 46 career games under his belt, Carlile's journey to the NHL is still in its early stages. The possibility of him practicing alongside Erik Karlsson in September adds an intriguing layer to this narrative.
Hendrix Lapierre: The Underrated Center
Hendrix Lapierre, often overlooked, could be a surprise package. His ability to play center, a position of need for the Penguins, makes him an intriguing prospect. While expectations are low, Lapierre has shown glimpses of positive impact in his career. The idea of him consistently playing and making a difference is not far-fetched. A surprise for Lapierre would be to become a regular in the lineup and contribute positively, especially with the center position still being a question mark for the team.
Nick Robertson: The Producing Winger
Nick Robertson, acquired from Toronto, has been productive despite limited ice time. With the Penguins' overstock of scoring-line wingers, Robertson's role is uncertain. However, his goal-scoring prowess (31 goals in the last two seasons) and steady progression make him a potential surprise. The Pens' depth at the position might force Robertson to step up and become a key player. The possibility of him scoring 20 goals and surpassing 40 points without extensive power play time could be a pleasant surprise for the fan base.
Bill Zonnon: The Rising Star from the AHL
Bill Zonnon, a 20-year-old center, is a long shot but an exciting prospect. With the Penguins' willingness to call up players from the AHL, Zonnon's potential is worth exploring. His performance in the AHL playoffs, scoring in each of his first three games, showcases his talent. Zonnon's speed, net-crashing ability, and center position make him a player to watch. While an NHL look in 2026-27 might be a stretch, his impression in Wilkes could lead to an unexpected call-up, following in the footsteps of Ben Kindel.
Mikhail Ilyin: The Playmaking Sensation
Mikhail Ilyin, a 21-year-old playmaker, flashed in the AHL playoffs, scoring nine points in 15 games. His playmaking abilities and hockey IQ are undeniable, and his success at every level suggest a player with NHL potential. While it might be a stretch to expect an immediate impact, Ilyin could surprise by blossoming into a solid AHL player and potentially stepping up when the conditions are right. The Penguins' willingness to give young players a chance makes Ilyin a name to remember.
In the world of hockey, surprises are the spice of life. These potential surprise players add an element of excitement to the upcoming season. While some are more likely than others, the Penguins' history of discovering hidden gems makes these possibilities all the more intriguing. As the season unfolds, keep an eye on these players, for they might just become the next big surprise in Pittsburgh.
